The Fairway

Golf, straight down the middle

International

Why America wins the Presidents Cup and loses the Ryder Cup

Golf.com asks why the U.S. dominates the Presidents Cup but folds against Europe — the answer is about opponents, not talent.

The Fairway Desk · September 21, 2026 · 2 min read

Aerial view of 14th, 15th and 16th holes at Portmarnock Golf Club, Ireland

The United States turns up at Medinah this week as the heavy favourite it almost always is in this event, and rarely turns up that way against Europe. Golf.com lays out the split and asks the obvious question: same players, same format, wildly different record. The answer isn’t mystery — it’s structural.

The opponent, not the format

Both competitions run on match play, both use a mix of foursomes, fourballs and singles, both hand a captain wildcard picks. What differs is who’s standing on the other side of the tee box. Europe’s Ryder Cup teams draw from a continent’s worth of tours, decades of joint scouting through the DP World Tour pipeline, and a culture that treats the event as the summit of a career. The International team at the Presidents Cup draws from a looser federation of countries with no shared tour feeding it, no unified selection system, and — crucially — far less depth once you get past four or five genuine stars. A weaker, more fragmented opponent produces a different tournament even when the American roster is identical.

That asymmetry compounds itself. Europe’s players grow up believing the Ryder Cup is winnable, because it regularly is. International team players, by contrast, inherit a competition their side has rarely led, which shapes belief before a ball is struck. Belief, in match play, is not a soft factor — it decides who takes the risky line off the tee in a one-hole match with the format on the line.

Pressure without history

The Ryder Cup carries a century of narrative weight, hostile away crowds, and a domestic media cycle that turns every session into referendum on the American game. The Presidents Cup carries none of that. American players by their own admission play looser when the story isn’t already written for them — which is also why Scottie Scheffler’s frustration with “narratives” this week, reported separately, lands the way it does. The Presidents Cup lets the U.S. team be good at golf without also being good at absorbing external pressure. The Ryder Cup demands both, and that second skill has not been reliably present in recent American teams regardless of world ranking.

None of this means the Presidents Cup is a lesser trophy for the players lifting it. It means the two competitions are measuring different things — one measures who has the better twelve golfers this week, the other measures who can carry the weight of the room while playing them. Snedeker’s team will find out this week which one Medinah turns out to be.

Reported at Golf.com; analysis ours.

Newsletter

Golf, straight down the middle

Get The Fairway in your inbox. No spam, and one click to leave.

Subscribe

Every morning · Unsubscribe any time. We never sell or rent your address; read the privacy policy.

Return to the issue

Newsletter

Subscribe to The Fairway

Golf, straight down the middle · Every morning

One click to leave, any time — no login and no follow-up sequence. We never sell or rent your address. See the privacy policy.

Unsubscribe

Leave The Fairway list

Enter the address you subscribed with. We remove it and keep a suppression record so an imported list cannot add you back.

Fastest route: the Unsubscribe link at the bottom of any email we sent you — it removes you immediately, no form. Full options on the unsubscribe page.